From January through September 2026, the Village of Hinsdale issued 14 permits for new single-family houses, and at least 10 of them included tearing down the house already on the lot. In the same nine months it issued 105 permits for residential alterations and remodels and 12 for residential additions. That works out to about eight permits for work on an existing house for every permit for a new one. The village posts each month's report on its building permit activity page.
Those totals point to a practical takeaway for anyone weighing an older Hinsdale house. Most of the permits for work on the village's housing stock are for keeping houses standing. Teardowns happen less often, and the recorded purchase prices behind them fall mostly within a narrow band. If you know where that band sits, you know which listings may also be on a builder's list and which ones are mostly being bought by people who plan to keep the house.
What the replaced houses last sold for
The Hinsdalean prints recorded property transfers every week. Five of 2026's demolish-and-rebuild permits can be matched to a recent purchase price in that column.
| Address | Recorded purchase | Builder on 2026 permit | Declared cost of new house | Permit issued |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 35 W. Birchwood Ave. | $610,000, Feb. 5, 2025 | Courtyard Custom Builders | $900,000 | Feb. 2026 |
| 116 Minneola St. | $720,000, May 29, 2025 | Homecrafters LLC | $1,200,000 | Feb. 2026 |
| 903 S. Madison St. | $727,500, Oct. 7, 2025 | 4 Star Builders | $1,200,000 | May 2026 |
| 305 S. Garfield St. | $950,000, Dec. 30, 2024 | S Kos Properties | $1,200,000 | May 2026 |
| 418 E. Sixth St. | $2,175,000, June 20, 2024 | J Jordan Homes | $2,000,000 | Feb. 2026 |
Sources for the table: transfers from The Hinsdalean for Birchwood, Minneola, Madison, Garfield and Sixth Street, plus the village's monthly permit reports.
Four of the five purchases fell between $610,000 and $950,000. In each of those four, the declared cost for the new house was higher than the recorded sale price of the old one. The declared cost is the valuation filed on the permit application. It is not a sale price, and it says nothing about what the finished house will list for. It does give a rough sense of each project's size. On these four lots, the money going into construction ran between about 1.3 and 1.7 times what the existing house sold for.
The time between purchase and permit varied a lot. 903 S. Madison went from recorded sale to permit in about seven months, and 116 Minneola in about nine. 35 W. Birchwood took about a year. 305 S. Garfield and 418 E. Sixth took well over a year.
The teardowns without a recorded price follow the same pattern
The other demolish-and-rebuild permits issued in 2026 carry declared costs in the same general range. Homecrafters filed the largest one, $2,253,000 for 121 N. Adams St. in February. Flex Development declared $900,000 at 944 S. Grant St. in April. AMB Associates declared $850,000 at 5526 S. County Line Road in July, and Timber Trails Building declared $1,500,000 at 526 Woodside Ave. in September.
At least one permit was for a new house on land with no house to tear down. McNaughton Development's permit for 946 S. Garfield St. in April lists "NSF on vacant lot" at a declared $1,000,000. Oakley Home Builders pulled a $1,000,000 new-house permit for 332 Fuller Road in July, and its own project page for The Oaks now lists that house as sold. Even so, at least 10 of the 14 new-house permits issued through September started with a demolition.
505 S. County Line Road is a separate case. The Hinsdalean reported in October 2025 that the 1901 Krehbiel mansion there had been razed. The property sold for $7.5 million in 2022, and the owner had initial Zoning Board of Appeals approval to divide the 2.76 acres into three home sites. Timber Trails Building pulled a $2,000,000 new-house permit at that address in March 2026. Estate parcels that can be subdivided are a different market from the typical teardown, and their numbers should not be used to price a 1950s house on a standard lot.
Sixth Street shows both outcomes on one block
East Sixth Street has both outcomes within a short walk. 418 E. Sixth St. sold for $2,175,000 in June 2024, and J Jordan Homes received a demolish-and-rebuild permit there in February 2026 with a declared cost of $2,000,000.
A few doors west, 208 E. Sixth St. sold in September 2025 for $4.45 million. The Hinsdalean reported that the house was built in 1925 for Edward Warren Everett and designed by Marshall & Fox, the firm behind the Blackstone and Drake hotels in Chicago. In November 2025 it became the 100th property on the village's Historically Significant Structures Property List, and the new owners planned a renovation using the village's historic preservation incentives.
The higher price went to the house being kept. In Hinsdale, a high sale price does not mean a builder bought the house. At the top of the market, a well-preserved house with a documented history can sell for more than the land under it would bring a builder.
The renovation side keeps growing
The village started the Historically Significant Structures Property List in 2022, and joining is voluntary. In its Nov. 11, 2026 report, The Hinsdalean said the Historic Preservation Commission and Village Board expected to add eight more homes, which would bring the total to 109. Trustees signaled support and scheduled their vote for Nov. 17.
The eight candidates are spread across the village. 7 W. Ayres St. dates to 1866 and was built for Anson Ayres, one of Hinsdale's founders. 218 E. Hickory St. is an 1900 Queen Anne that was once home to Harry N. Baum, son of "The Wizard of Oz" author L. Frank Baum. 425 S. Monroe St. is a 1907 American Four-Square that was divided into three apartments at some point and later returned to a single-family home. The owners of 730 S. Lincoln St., a circa-1890 house, want to restore its open porch. The rest of the group is 120 S. Elm St., 108 Minneola St., 427 N. Vine St. and 404 N. Washington St.
Eight house numbers separate 108 Minneola, a candidate for the list, from 116 Minneola, where Homecrafters pulled a demolish-and-rebuild permit in February.
The shift has been building for a while. Patch reported in October 2024 that village officials were already crediting the incentive program with more renovations. Bill Haarlow of the Historic Preservation Commission told the Village Board then, "We're getting many more of these types of situations where people are renovating rather than tearing down." The 2026 permit totals are consistent with that.
Some of the village's best-known older houses still come down. Demolition crews were scheduled in early October 2025 to take down the 1869 William Whitney House at 142 E. First St. in the Robbins Park Subdivision. In an October 2025 editorial, The Hinsdalean reported that Legacy Builders owns the lot and plans a 6,841-square-foot "transitional French country" house there.
Reading an older Hinsdale listing with these numbers
These figures are useful when you look at an older Hinsdale house that needs work. If it is priced in the $600,000s to the low $900,000s, that is the range where houses sold in 2024 and 2025 before their lots got teardown permits in 2026. In that range, a buyer who plans to keep the house may be bidding against one who plans to replace it.
Across the whole village, the 2026 permits were mostly remodels and additions, about eight for every new house. For older houses with a documented history, the village's list, which stood at 101 homes before the eight candidates went to the board on Nov. 17, comes with possible access to grants, tax breaks and other incentives, according to The Hinsdalean. If you are buying in this range, plan your budget around renovating the house rather than replacing it.
This also applies to sellers. If you own an older house in Hinsdale, you need to know which of these two groups your likely buyers fall into before you set a price. Our earlier guide on preparing a historic Hinsdale home for today's buyer covers the renovation side, and the Hinsdale neighborhood page has current listings.
FAQ
Which builders were most active on Hinsdale teardowns in 2026? From January through September 2026, Homecrafters LLC and Timber Trails Building each appear on two new-house permits. Homecrafters had 121 N. Adams St. and 116 Minneola St. Timber Trails had 526 Woodside Ave. and 505 S. County Line Road.
How much construction value did 2026's new Hinsdale houses represent? The 14 new single-family permits issued from January through September 2026 carried a combined declared valuation of $17,053,000. Remodels and additions together came to about $12.9 million across 117 permits in the same period. Individual new-house valuations ranged from $500,000 to $2,253,000.
If you own an older Hinsdale house, we can tell you whether its likely buyer is a builder or a family that will renovate, and price it for that buyer before it goes on the market. Christine Wilczek and Jason Bacza track Hinsdale's permits and recorded sales street by street. Request a Free Home Valuation to see where your house falls.