Close view of an oak entry door beneath a dark timber canopy, with buff limestone, charcoal brick, gray stone steps and copper-colored ornamental grasses.

Downtown Hinsdale New Businesses and Ownership Updates: Fall 2026

Twenty-five years ago, Craig Zoberis and his wife, Tracy, had a white chocolate mousse wedding cake from Toni's Patisserie & Café. A couple of weeks ago, Toni Cox made the top tier again for their early anniversary. This time Zoberis was one of the bakery's three owners.

His story is one of several from the past year. Across downtown Hinsdale and out on York Road, buildings and businesses that sat with the same owners for decades are being sold. The buyers are mostly people who live a few blocks away.

The recipes came with the bakery

Earlier this year, Zoberis bought Toni's with two other Hinsdale residents, Mark Konieczka and Tom Wake. The sellers were Toni Cox and her husband, Paul Pell, who opened the shop 32 years ago. The bakery is at 51 S. Washington St.

The deal nearly went to someone else. Zoberis spotted the listing in November through Eatz, a broker that sells restaurant businesses, and recognized the bakery from the description alone. Cox was already working with another buyer at the time. When that deal fell through in the first week of January, the broker called Zoberis.

All three owners bring different backgrounds. Wake worked in wholesale distribution, Konieczka worked in commercial real estate, and Wake calls Zoberis "a serial entrepreneur and engineer." About ten years ago, Konieczka and his wife, Stephanie, who studied at Le Cordon Bleu in Paris, thought about opening a cupcake shop in Hinsdale.

Cox's recipes were part of the sale, so customers' favorites will stay the same. Cox described the recipe files as "everything from hand-written to typed up to in the computer system," some stained from years of use. "It's a bit like passing down your grandmother's recipes," she said. She is staying on through the transition, and Steve Rennau is staying on as director of operations.

The owners say they have no plans for immediate changes. Later on, they may expand a drink menu that has been limited to wine and beer. They applied for a new village liquor license and expected to receive it this month. "Perhaps there are bloody Marys in the future," Konieczka said.

Five buildings, one corner, one owner who walks between them

Toni's changed owners. At First and Washington, the buildings themselves changed owners.

Pete Tortorello has lived in Hinsdale for 20 years. Since November 2025, he and his company, Fairfield Properties, have bought five downtown buildings, with investors he says are "many of whom are local." His office is at 11 E. First St., down the street from the rest.

"It's kind of fun - I can walk from building to building." Pete Tortorello, in The Hinsdalean

Here is what he owns and what each building is becoming, according to The Hinsdalean's September report:

  • 11-21 E. First St. His first purchase, in November 2025. Ten Friends, Sweet William and Blue Mercury are on the ground floor, with apartments and offices upstairs, including his own office.
  • 102 S. Washington St. John Papenhausen built it in 1888 for his tailoring business, and his family of eight lived on the second floor. At the time it was the only commercial building on the south side of First Street. Alixandra Blue and Studio W stay downstairs. Above them, a two-floor, 2,025-square-foot apartment Tortorello calls the "Owners Unit" is listed at $7,000 a month. Its turret window looks out over the business district.
  • 8-10 W. First St. Tortorello calls it the "yellow house." It is getting gray siding and new HVAC and electrical systems before Frame Bridge, a national online custom framing company, moves in.
  • The one-story building behind 8-10 W. First. A 700-square-foot former salon getting a bay window, skylights and an accessible bathroom. The door is moving east to line up with a walkway out to First Street. Rent will be $4,000 a month. Tortorello says the parking area beside it could become a paver patio, and he would like to see a food tenant there: "I think we need more food options for quick bites in Hinsdale."
  • 104-106 S. Washington St. The second-floor offices above My Eye Doctor will become four one-bedroom apartments of 670 to 840 square feet as office leases expire. The switch means installing sprinklers throughout the building.

The apartments get less attention than the storefronts, but they matter just as much. Tortorello estimates downtown has only 20 to 25 apartments, most of them vintage and "tucked away" where "people don't know about them." He sees demand from residents who sell their houses but want to stay in town in a smaller space.

He is also clear that rents will rise once the buildings are improved. "You're making a significant investment in the property and there's a lot of spending power in the community," he said. "I have investors and want to deliver a better product, and that costs money."

Why so many buildings are for sale at once

Tortorello says many downtown buildings owned by the same families for decades have recently changed hands. DuPage County Recorder of Deeds records show three of those sales in the fall of 2025:

  • 18 W. First St., the former Expressions Gallery of Fine Art, sold for $1.93 million on Sept. 10.
  • 11 E. First St., home to Ten Friends, sold for $4.5 million on Nov. 19. That was Tortorello's first purchase.
  • A building on S. Washington Street sold for $2.2 million on Dec. 4.

In January, 102 S. Washington and 104-106 S. Washington were both on the market, and both now belong to Fairfield.

Buyers can move fast because there is almost nothing available. In the fourth quarter of 2025, the central business district's retail vacancy rate was 2 percent, according to figures the village got from Choose DuPage. Assistant Village Manager Andrianna Peterson told The Hinsdalean the village has "a lot of interest and not really enough inventory to match all of the interest."

So downtown space mostly turns over when a building sells, and buyers who already know the block can act quickly when one does.

Out on York Road, the same pattern

Gateway Square opened in 1985 and has 38,800 square feet in two buildings at 777 N. York Road, near Ogden Avenue. In early 2024, a village Economic Development Commission meeting noted closures at the center. Five Kings Properties bought it in October 2025 for $8.3 million.

New tenants arrived this summer. Alison Kozlow, a Hinsdale resident since February 2020, opened The Book Nook on Aug. 12. She designed the children's bookshop herself and chose every title. Families can rent it for birthday parties and book clubs, and she plans to add story times and author readings. Paris312 opened next door. It sold party decor online for ten years before taking this storefront, and the production side of the shop stocks balloons in about 20 shades of teal and blue alone. The two shops held a joint grand opening on Sept. 19.

Sage Wellness Sanctuary, owned by Bianca Castlebuono, was set to open this month in about 2,800 square feet. It will offer yoga, meditation, spa treatments, contrast therapy suites and an elixir bar. Michele Zayed's I Design Salon & Blow Dry Bar, a longtime tenant, tripled its space in February. Kozlow points out that every business that opened at the center in the past year is woman-owned.

The renovation comes next. Property manager Ramis Memishi says the courtyard will be rebuilt and the signage, lighting and parking lot all replaced. "No surface is being left untouched," he said. The target is 2027, pending village approvals. When Memishi presented early plans in May, commissioners suggested renaming the center "Gateway on York."

Two openings that are approved but not open yet

Two more local projects have cleared village approvals but have no confirmed opening date.

The village-owned Brush Hill depot at 25 E. Hinsdale Ave. has been empty since Casa Margarita's lease ended in May 2025. On April 21, the Village Board approved a lease with Lou and Julie Rubin for Hometown Coffee and Juice. The lease requires at least $1.25 million in interior improvements, and the April report set an opening goal of the end of 2026. No local coverage since then has reported on construction.

At 50 S. Garfield Ave., Sam and Patricia Vlahos, who own Fuller House next door, are planning Humble Patty, a burger and soft-serve shop. In June, the Village Board approved the site plans and outdoor dining. Occupancy depends on installing a safety barrier between the dining area and nearby parking. Sam Vlahos had hoped to open by Labor Day. A Hinsdale Journal report later in June said no opening date had been confirmed.

Both are the kind of quick-bite spots Tortorello says downtown needs.

October dates downtown

The Chamber and the village have several events this fall that bring people past these storefronts:

  • Thursday, Oct. 8, 5 to 8 p.m. The Hinsdale Chamber's 7th Annual Wine Walk.
  • Monday, Oct. 12, 7 a.m. to 1 p.m. The last farmers market of the season, at 30 E. Chicago Ave.
  • Thursday, Oct. 15, noon. A ribbon-cutting at Herbal Touch Wellness & Spa, 10 E. Hinsdale Ave., second floor.
  • Saturday, Oct. 17, 9 a.m. to 4 p.m. The downtown Fall Sidewalk Sale.
  • Saturday, Oct. 24, 11 a.m. to 2 p.m. The village's free Fall Family Fest at Hinsdale Middle School and downtown, with trick-or-treating at participating businesses and pumpkins for the first 500 participants.

The 60th Annual Christmas Walk follows on Friday, Dec. 4, from 5 to 7 p.m., with Santa, a tree lighting, a holiday train and a carousel. This will be the first holiday season for Toni's new owners. Cox calls the fourth quarter "a huge thing for us and a lot of work."

If you own a home or building near downtown and want to know how this year's sales and renovations affect its value, Christine Wilczek and Jason Bacza can walk you through the numbers. Request a Free Home Valuation, and we will base it on the sales happening around your block.

Work With Us

Get assistance in determining current property value, crafting a competitive offer, writing and negotiating a contract, and much more. Contact us today.

Follow Me on Instagram